We had never been there. In fact, we had never heard of it until about two weeks ago. But the rave reviews on the web made us add this to our list of “must eats.” And we were not disappointed.
The café has been described by many as a “hole in the wall.” Now we have eaten in many a hole in the wall and Mary & Tito’s doesn’t fit that description.
The menu does not break new ground with the kitchen’s creativity. You will find the usual assortment of burritos, enchiladas, and tacos along with stuffed sopapillas, carne adovado, and chile relleno. The sopappilas, or "Mexican turnovers,” resemble an overgrown empanada or Italian calzone. It's made from sopapilla dough and may be stuffed with cheese, meat, beans, or rice and then deep fried. Chuck, deciding to eat outside the box, selected the bean and cheese stuffed sopapilla, which did not come with either beans or rice. So he announced that he would eat mine.
What arrived was an enormous sopapilla slathered with the café’s famous green chile with meat.
The menu also listed the daily specials, and on the day of our visit, the special ($6.00) was the large combination plate – one ground beef taco, one rolled cheese enchilada, and one cheddar-stuffed chile relleno with rice and beans (which Chuck ate) on the side. I usually order the red chile, which is the café’s specialty, but I prefer the green on a chile relleno. Since my experience with “Christmas” (both red and green on the plate) has been mixed with the two blending together in a muddle that obscures both flavors, I ordered the green. Was I glad I did.
Since Chuck ate my rice and beans, this allowed me to order a side of guacamole. Seemingly lacking in lime juice and cilantro, this was the only minor disappointment of the lunch.
For what seems to be authentic New Mexican food at very reasonable prices (our lunch, with two ice teas, only cost $20.57 before the tip), Mary & Tito’s Café can’t be beat and earns a 4.5 Addie rating.
Before paying our bill, we looked at several family photographs by the
"Yes, I am. I've been here 50 years . . .," Mary began, as she reached out to shake his hand.
"Fifty years?" Chuck interrupted.
"Yes, 5-0 years. My husband was a fireman when he had this idea about opening a restaurant. My head cook has been here for 27 years, and his assistant has been here for 26 years," Mary proudly responded.
"I really enjoyed the chile relleno," I said, "especially with the green chile."
Appearing younger than her years, it was clear that Mary enjoyed people and enjoyed preparing some of the finest New Mexican food in the state.